How to set realistic social media goals for food and wellness brands

You’ve likely heard that you need social media goals to grow online – more followers, more likes, more engagement. But what does that actually mean when you’re running a food or wellness brand? When your time is limited, your offers are seasonal or service-based, and you’re already juggling several platforms?

This is the question most guides ignore. I work with food and wellness professionals who want results that actually move the needle: reaching the right people, building trust, and generating meaningful enquiries. Before that can happen, your goals need to reflect where your business truly is and what it needs.

This guide will walk you through how to set realistic, measurable, and effective social media goals. Zero fluff. Just clear steps to help you get better outcomes from the work you already do.

Before we dive in, it’s worth acknowledging something that often gets overlooked in these types of guides: every business is different.

Your goals should reflect that. A framework that works brilliantly for one brand might not be the right fit for another — and that’s not a flaw. It’s a reminder to adapt advice to your own context. That includes your business stage, your offers, how much time you actually have, and how you want to show up online.

There’s no one-size-fits-all path, but there is a way to approach goal setting with more clarity. A way that avoids vague buzzwords and focuses instead on results that actually matter: building trust, attracting aligned clients, and growing sustainably without burning out in the process.

This guide is designed for founders in the food and wellness space who are ready to use social media more intentionally.

1. Why most social media goals fail

Before we dive in, let’s clear the air: most social media goals fail not because you lack effort, but because they’re built on shaky foundations (and no strategy). Here’s why:

They don’t connect to your business stage. A brand-new wellness coach with no email list shouldn’t obsess over monthly bookings. They need awareness first.
They focus on vanity metrics. Likes and followers feel good, but they rarely translate to bookings or sales.
They ignore capacity. If you’re a solo brand, you can’t post daily without burning out.
They try to do it all. One goal per 3–6 months works better than a wishlist of ten.

The result? You feel stuck, unsure what’s working, and overwhelmed when growth stalls.

2. The three goal types that actually help

Instead of chasing vanity metrics, orient your goals around results. There are three types that matter most:

a) Growth goals

These focus on building your audience with intention. Examples:

“Gain 500 engaged email subscribers in six months.”
“Reach 50,000 unique viewers on Pinterest pins related to recipe development.”

These are results that matter because you can reconnect with people later — through newsletters, offers, or new content.

b) Conversion goals

These are about getting people to take an action connected to your offers. Examples:

“Book 5 new discovery calls per month via Instagram CTA links.”
“Sell 20 recipe packs in a quarter through Pinterest clicks.”

These goals are tied directly to what you sell and build your revenue.

c) Content ecosystem goals

Consider how content performs across platforms. Examples:

“Reuse one blog post into 3 social formats every week.”
“Get 100 saves on a carousel post about cooking methods.”

These support long-term growth by adding value and efficiency into your content strategy.

3. Match your goals to your brand stage

Different stages call for different goals. Here’s a simple framework:

a) Early phase (0–6 months)

Growth goals matter most. Gain followers who care.
Keep conversions modest while gathering feedback.
Focus on consistent content creation.

b) Mid phase (6–18 months)

Keep growing your audience while beginning to sell digital products or services.
Track bookings and sales more closely.
Add ecosystem goals to build consistency and reuse strategy.

c) Established phase (18+ months)

Focus more on conversions and sales.
Optimise the content ecosystem to reduce effort.
Consider new platforms or advanced strategies once core goals are met.

4. Metrics that matter (and those to ignore)

Knowing what to measure can simplify your life.

a) Metrics that matter:

Reach / Impressions – are people seeing your content?
Profile clicks and link clicks – are they moving toward you?
Newsletter sign-ups – ideal signposts for nurturing.
Discovery calls or sales – real-world outcomes.

b) Metrics to ignore:

Likes without engagement – they offer little strategic value.
Raw follower counts – unless it directly supports your growth goal.
Top posts for ego, not action – common traps that derail focus.

The numbers you choose should help answer one question: Is this helping me reach my goal?

5. How to set your own social media goals in four steps

Anchor to a business objective. What are you really trying to achieve? More clients? Product sales? Brand awareness?
Pick one platform to focus on. Depth beats spread.
Get specific. Write: “In six months, I aim for 1,000 email sign-ups from Instagram, then sell 10 packages from those leads.”
Check your capacity. Can you commit to one post/week? One blog monthly? Adjust accordingly to stay consistent.

6. Case study scenarios

a) A nutritionist launching a course

Goal: 100 course sign-ups in six months.
Strategy:

Build anticipation with weekly video snippets + Expert Q+As on Instagram.
Add a lead magnet and track sign-ups.
Soft sell through email series, then launch with testimonials and urgency.

b) A local bakery increasing footfall

Goal: 20% more walk-in visits over three months.
Strategy:

Use daily Instagram Stories to highlight specials and prep rituals.
Run a “mention our post for a free sample” offer once a week to track results.
Photograph each batch in a bright, consistent style to build brand recognition.

c) A wellness brand prepping for product launch

Goal: Build 5,000 email subscribers to launch digital cookbooks.
Strategy:

Create a series of 5 e-book previews and repurpose into pins, Reels, and email content.
Set a weekly pin reach goal (e.g., 50k impressions/week).
Leverage a giveaway campaign to expand reach and sign-ups.

7. Avoid these common goal‑setting mistakes

Goal overload – Too many weak goals, zero focus. Pick one scaleable goal per quarter.
Misaligned aims – Don’t track pins if your priority is email sign-ups.
No plan to review – Audit monthly: what’s working? What needs adjusting?
All hype, no habit – Daily lifestyle updates may be charming, but they don’t build consistency.

8. Consistency vs frequency

Posting daily on every channel isn’t sustainable — even big teams don’t always do it. Instead:

Pick a rhythm (e.g., two posts/week + one newsletter/month) and stick to it.
Use evergreen and reusable visuals where possible.
If a shot or story worked well once, find new ways to highlight it.

Consistency lets you commit; frequency alone leads to burnout.

9. Final goal‑setting checklist

Before you move forward, check your goals against this list:

✔️ Is it measurable?
✔️ Will it support a business outcome?
✔️ Can you sustain the content pace?
✔️ Does it fit your mindset and brand tone?
✔️ Do you plan to review periodically?

If any answer is no, pause and revise.

Ready to turn strategy into results?

If you’re feeling stuck or unsure about your next steps, I can help. Whether you need a strategy built from scratch or just a fresh perspective on what’s working, get in touch and let’s get your food brand moving in the right direction.

I’m a social media manager and strategist, content creator, and food photographer based in Dublin, Ireland. With eight years of experience working remotely with food and wellness brands worldwide, I create marketing strategies and visuals that resonate with your audience and truly support your business goals.

Fill out this quick form